How the heroes of the three discussions were smeared, refuting the **** boss "Ningyuan War" article [blog post]

A few days ago, I wrote two summary articles on the situation of the **** boss tampering with history books and fabricating pseudo-history when discussing the issue of Yuan Chonghuan, for 43 questions. The big guy only replied slightly after the first article (only 2 of the 30 questions were hastily answered, and after I gave the photocopy of the history book, I still had to claim that it was a mistake in the history book and not I tampered with it), and the second article turned a blind eye to it completely. originally thought that this person would know a little more after he could not respond, and no longer use tampering with history books and fabricating fake history to deceive ordinary netizens, but he didn't expect to relapse after two days, and continued to play cutting and patchwork, taking quotes out of context and deliberately misinterpreting magic skills, and once again concocted the absurd and ridiculous article "Yuan Chonghuan is guilty of "throwing away grain and abandoning the island" in the "Ningyuan War". The full text intercepted several fragments of the historical materials of the Ming and Qing dynasties, the logic was unclear, upside down, and a large handful of footcloths were smeared with Hu Li, and Yuan Chonghuan was charged with a crime in a daze. In view of this, the author tried to sort out the sequence of development of the events and the relevant historical materials one by one, and gradually debunked the text tricks played by the **** boss in the process.

It all started in September of the fifth year of the Apocalypse. During this month, a large-scale battle took place in Liaodong: the Battle of Liuhe. The result of this battle was the defeat of the Ming army, and the direct result was that Sun Chengzong, the governor of Jiliao, was dismissed in October of that year, and at the same time, Ma Shilong, the chief soldier of Liaodong, who was directly responsible, and Yu Anxing, the governor of Liaodong, was also implicated in this matter and was deposed in November. Sun Chengzong was succeeded by the new Liaodong Jing slightly Gaodi. What needs to be added here is that in the late Ming Dynasty, in terms of the Liaodong battlefield, the rights and responsibilities of the two positions of Jiliao Inspector and Liaodong Economic Strategy are actually the same, and the difference is only that the honor of Jiliao Supervisor is higher. The first person to get the position of Jiliao Inspector was Sun Chengzong, and the setting of the "Supervisor" was mainly because Sun Chengzong was the emperor. But since Sun Chengzong, those who serve as the superintendent of Jiliao do not have to be the emperor's master, and this name has been extended to be a kind of honor and the emperor's weight. After Sun Chengzong, Wang Zhichen and Yuan Chonghuan were also appointed as the superintendent of Jiliao. In addition, such as Xiong Tingbi, Wang Zaijin, and Gao Di, they all served as Liaodong Economic Strategy. However, in fact, the Liaodong Jingluo and the Jiliao Governor nominally govern Ji, Liao, Deng, and Jin (in fact, Jizhen belongs to the jurisdiction of the Jiliao Governor), and they are basically awarded the Shang Fang Sword (except for Wang Zaijin), and they are mainly responsible for fighting against the Houjin, so there is no essential difference in power and responsibility.

Sun Chengzong guarded Liao for four years, and his merits were great, "before and after repairing the nine cities and forty-five forts, training 110,000 soldiers, 12 chariot battalions, five water battalions, two fire battalions, and eight forward and rear strength battalions, making armor, instruments, bows and arrows, artillery, canals, and halogen tools totaled millions, expanding the land for 400 li, opening 5,000 hectares, and earning 150,000 per year." After Shuning Yuangong, there are thousands of households in the world. Among these achievements, the most important is to "expand the land for four hundred miles", that is, to restore the land outside the Shanhaiguan Pass of the Ming Dynasty that Xiong Tingbi lost to Jinzhou. Therefore, Sun Chengzong was actually the first person to build the Ningjin defense line at the end of the Ming Dynasty. However, after Gao Di took office, he resolutely suspended Sun Chengzong's plan to restore the Liao land because he was afraid of failure, and gave up the land outside the Guan, hoping to shrink the whole army into the Shanhai Pass. "The Biography of Yuan Chonghuan in the History of the Ming Dynasty" records: In October, Chengzong stopped, and Gao Di came to the generation, saying that the outside of the pass must not be guarded, and ordered to withdraw the brocade and the right city guards, and move its soldiers to the pass. Du Tuntong sentenced Jin Qiliang to Chonghuan and said: "The three cities of Jin, You, and Daling are all forwards. If the troops are collected and retreated, the people who have been safe will be replanted, and the feudal territory that has been obtained will be lost again, and the inside and outside the border can be retreated several times!" Chonghuan also strived for it, saying: "The art of war has advanced but not retreated. The three cities have been restored, and Encore is lightly withdrawn, and the right is shaken, and the former is shocked, and the closure of the door is also unsafe. But now the good will be kept, and there will be no other worries. "The first intention is strong, and I want to withdraw Ning, the first two cities. Chonghuan said: "I'd rather go to the front of the road, the official should die here, I won't go." "The first is not difficult, but to withdraw Jinzhou, Youtun, Da, Xiaolinghe and Songshan, Xingshan, Tashan guards, drive the troops into the customs, abandon more than 100,000 rice millet, and the death of the journey, crying shock, the people are resentful and the army is sluggish.

In this paragraph, the **** boss made a big fuss, obviously "the first is not difficult, but to withdraw Jinzhou, Youtun, Da, Xiaolinghe and Songshan, Xingshan, Tashan guards, drive the troops into the customs, and abandon more than 100,000 rice millet, and the death is carried on the way, the cry is shocking, the people are dissatisfied and the army is not good." After cutting and piecing together several pieces of his historical materials, he denied each other, and finally put the responsibility for the loss of food on Yuan Chonghuan's head.

First of all, what is the reason for Gao Di's withdrawal from the outside of the pass? **** The big man's statement is that "when Gao arrived in office in the tenth month, Mongolia and Houjin were already in a state of war due to famine, and in Gao Di's view, no matter what the outcome of the war was, Houjin was very likely to pass on the losses of the famine and war to the Ming Dynasty, so he immediately began to discuss the matter of 'withdrawing Jin and right' after taking office", "After Sun Chengzong stepped down, Gao Di took over, and in the face of the situation at that time, in response to Houjin's attempt to rob the Ming Dynasty's grain, Gao Di was determined to obtain accurate information." This decision is completely correct, and it is by no means a hasty escape, but a decisive decision formed after studying and judging the facts. ”

Let's take a look at the first article first, when Gao arrived in office, were Mongolia and Houjin really in a state of war? Please read this article friends remember, all the **** bigwigs did not give the details of the historical evidence, nine times out of ten there are doubts; even if the historical evidence is given, it is three points of tampering, three points of interception, three points of misinterpretation, and the real one is only one percent. "Qing Taizu Record", "On the fifth day of the first month of November, Oba coaxed Taiji to send five envoys to tell him urgently: "Lingdan Khan raised troops to invade, and its momentum has been seen. Then the emperor sent the soldiers from all over the place, and on the 10th day of the first month, he led the kings and ministers to lead a large army to help him. To the north pass of Kaiyuan Town, parade horses, because of the first shooting and hunting, the horse is very successful, is the selection of five thousand fine horses, ordered the three kings, the four kings, Abutai, the traces of Halang, Ajige, Shaotuo, Chahaliang Zhongtaiji, etc., led the troops to help, the emperor led the army back. The three kings and other soldiers went to the place of the Ao'an Tower, and its Lingdan Khan besieged the city of Oba for several days, and could not attack it, and heard that the Manchurian reinforcements arrived, and fled in a hurry, and the camels and horses were left behind, and the siege was solved, and the kings were returned. "OK, the war between Mongolia and Houjin is a matter of November, can it be unpredictable in the tenth month of Gao?

On the sixth day of the first month of the sixth year of the Apocalypse, that is, the eleventh year of the Mandate of Heaven (1626), Liaodong Jing slightly Gao Di reported: "The slave thief wants to covet the grain of Youtun and cross the river around the fifteenth day of the first month. ("Xizong Records") This record **** boss also quoted it. But by confusing the narrative order, he makes the unwary reader tend to overlook the great flaws in the chronological order. In the first month of the sixth year, Gao Di officially reported that Hou Jin had an attempt to rob the grain, and in October of the previous year, the **** boss was able to say nonsense, "In the face of the situation at that time, in response to the Hou Jin Dynasty's attempt to rob the grain of the Ming Dynasty, Gao Di decided to 'strengthen the wall and clear the wilderness' under the condition of obtaining accurate information", which is really a big joke in the world. The big guy's conclusion is that Gao Di's retreat was "a resolute decision made after studying and judging the facts," and what kind of "reality" was based on? In October of the fifth year of the Apocalypse, according to the "reality" of the first month of the sixth year of the Apocalypse! If this is really the case, it is too insulting for the **** big man to call the decisive decision too insulting to Gao Di's ability, and it should be called a stroke of genius.

So, in October, what was the real reason that led Gao Di to make up his mind to completely abandon the defense outside the Guan? Zhou Wenyu's "Bian Shi Xiaoji" said: "After the official departure, the central Gao Gongdi ordered the withdrawal of the troops in front of Jinyouning and the abandonment of the border 400 miles outside the Guan. In addition, Wang Zaijin's "Three Dynasties Liao Facts" also has the same record, "(in the first month of the sixth year) the military department, slave whistle Songshan, then Ning far and near. Due to the defeat of the Liuhe River, the old town was hastily withdrawn, and the right tun Daling stopped the sentry to rest, not for the land. Those who are in a hurry today, Ning Yuan also. Gaodi's retreat was definitely not because Ming Jianwanli estimated the advance of Houjin, but because of the "defeat of Liuhe". The conservative Gao Di was afraid of repeating Sun Chengzong's mistake of losing his official position due to the defeat of Liuhe, so he wanted to give up all the land outside the Guanguan and withdraw the army into Shanhaiguan, hoping to rely on the ability of Shanhaiguan to avoid military defeat as much as possible, and then did not hesitate to abandon the 400 miles of land that Sun Chengzong spent four years of hard work to recover, and did not hesitate to abandon hundreds of thousands of people outside the Guan.

Secondly, the official positions and terms of reference of Yuan Chonghuan and Jin Qiliang. In this record in the "Biography of Yuan Chonghuan in the History of the Ming Dynasty", Yuan Chonghuan said, "I would rather go to the front of the road, and the official should die here, and I will not go." Therefore, many people understand Yuan Chonghuan's official position in this matter as "Ning Qiandao". In fact, this statement is not accurate, Yuan Chonghuan's "Ning Qiandao" in this sentence is just an abbreviation, at this time his complete official title is "Ning Qian Dao Soldier Preparation Affairs", and it is recorded in the "National Legend" as "Ning Qiandao Deputy Envoy", which approximates the actual status of this official position. "Ningqian" refers to Ningyuan and Qiantun, so Yuan Chonghuan's actual official position is a deputy in charge of military affairs in the area from Ningyuan to Qiantun. In addition to Ningqian Road, there was also Jinzhou Road in Liaodong Town at this time. Jinzhou, Youtun, and Daling River all belong to Jinzhou Road, that is, they are not under the jurisdiction of Yuan Chonghuan. Therefore, even if Yuan Chonghuan opposed Gaodi's retreat, he could only violate the order in the way of "the county official is not as good as the current management" within the scope of Ningqian, and the soldiers and people in Jinyou and other places would not listen to his orders. Looking at Jin Qiliang again, his official position recorded in "The Biography of Yuan Chonghuan in the History of the Ming Dynasty" is the general judgment of Tun. The big guy just made a big fuss about the word "tun", and repeatedly mentioned "right tun" in the article, which made people mistakenly think that Jin Qiliang's scope of responsibility was right tun. In fact, it is very clear in Zhou Wenyu's "A Little Chronicle of Border Affairs", "Jin Qiqi and Ning Yuantong judged the matter." Qi Liang to the county to the county without harmless accumulation, His Majesty's foreign guard experience, effective for officials, quite ambitious, so to the general judgment. "The Biography of Yuan Chonghuan in the History of the Ming Dynasty" records, "Qi Liang is a small official, an official experience, the master rewards meritorious deeds, and is diligent and sensitive." Inherit the importance of the ancestor, use it as a general judgment, nuclear soldiers, horses, money and food, supervise the city work, manage the military and civilian lawsuits, and win the hearts of the people. Die, give Guanglu Shaoqing, and try 100 households in Shiqiao brocade clothes. Combining the two records, it is very clear that Jin Qiliang's position is Ning Yuantongju, that is, Yuan Chonghuan's direct subordinate, and the word "Inspector" in the official position does not refer to the supervision of Youtun, but refers to his daily work as "nuclear soldiers, horses, money and grain, and supervising city workers". According to the official positions of Yuan Chonghuan and Jin Qiliang, it is obvious that they have no jurisdiction over Jinzhou Youtun, but when Gao Di proposed a retreat plan, they raised doubts about this plan. This is also a reason for the **** boss to claim that the two of them are responsible for Jinyou's retreat. But those who know a little about the history of the Ming Dynasty will know that most of the people of the Ming Dynasty, especially the literati of the Ming Dynasty, have the style of worrying about the world first, and many things are not about themselves, but they can not die when they discuss it. In addition, even without my detailed analysis of the official position, just from the "Biography of Yuan Chonghuan in the History of the Ming Dynasty" It can be deduced from the records that the two have jurisdiction over Jinyou: if it is said that Jin Qiliang went to the anti-Shu because he had jurisdiction, then Yuan Chonghuan, who also went to the anti-Shu, should also have jurisdiction, then with Yuan Chonghuan's unstoppable attitude, he should be holding on to Jinzhou on the front line rather than Ningyuan after 200 miles; precisely because Yuan Chonghuan could only guard Ningyuan, it shows that even if he is on the top and cannot be removed from Jinyou, it does not mean that he has actual jurisdiction, and in the same way, Jin Qiliang's Shangshu does not mean that he has actual jurisdiction.

Third, about the grain of Youtun. In this problem, absurd speculations and clumsy tampering by **** bosses abound.

1. But a detail that must be mentioned is that there is no quantity of grain in Youtun, and it is only mentioned in the "Records of Qing Taizu" that "40,000 infantry" transported grain into "Youtun Guard", which shows that there is a lot of food, and "40,000 infantry" is enough to transport. As far as the unit of "stone" is concerned, in terms of accurate weight, the "Hanshu Law Chronicles" shall prevail: "Thirty catties are jun, and four jun are stones", that is, one hundred and two are city catties (60 kg). In the Song Dynasty, 1 stone is 92.5 Song Jin, Shen Kuo's "Mengxi Bi Tan" volume 3 recorded: "Where the stone is 92 and a half catties for the law, it is the Han scale 341 catties", so a stone of rice has 59,200 grams, that is, 59.2 kilograms, and the Han Dynasty is not much different, and later because a stone of grain happens to be the weight that a person can carry, so a stone is also called a dan, "stone" and "dan" are often used interchangeably. According to this data, the reason why Houjin arranged "40,000 infantry" should be because "40,000 people" happened to be able to transport them all at one time, and according to this idea, it is estimated that the grain lost in Youtun is almost "40,000 stones".

＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝

When I saw this analysis, I couldn't help but be deeply impressed by the sense of humor of the **** boss. After deducing the conversion of so many grain units, I actually came to the conclusion that the reason why Nurhachi arranged 40,000 people was because 40,000 people could transport them all at once.

The first thing to say is that the result of the "stone" of the **** boss is completely wrong, using the Song Dynasty's "Mengxi Pen Talk" to calculate the weight unit of the Ming Dynasty, Zhang Guan Li Dai's level is already a professional nine-dan. The "stone" of the Ming Dynasty is equivalent to about 94.4 kilograms now, please remember this common sense. Secondly, the derivation of this paragraph is not actually based on the weight of the grain at all to deduce why so much manpower is needed, but presupposes in advance that 40,000 soldiers will only make one trip, and each soldier will transport one stone, and then forcibly conclude that the total amount of food is 40,000 stone. The big guy still wants to turn the cause and effect relationship backwards, but when you look at his analysis process a little more seriously, you will find that this word game is really clumsy and ridiculous. Third, why did Nurhachi send 40,000 soldiers to transport food? The real reason was that he only had 40,000 logistical soldiers, that is, no armor soldiers. At this time, there are a total of 230 cattle recorded by Houjin, and the amount of each cow recorded strong men was set at 300, so the total number of Ding was only 6~70,000. The military service system of Houjin implements "one out of three soldiers", that is, one out of every three people is drawn as a soldier, so that two people are unarmoured soldiers. Therefore, in the sixth year of the Apocalypse, Nurhachi, who came out of the whole army, only had a total of 40,000 unarmored soldiers in his hands.

2. According to the record of "Qing Taizu Record": "The soldiers are about to go to the right cantonment, and the army and people led by Zhou Shoulian, the general who defended the city, have escaped...... The soldiers advanced, and the Jinzhou guerrillas Xiao Sheng, Zhang Xian of the Chinese army, Lu Zhong of the Dusi, Zuo Fu of the Songshan staff general, Mao Fengyi of the Chinese army, and the soldiers and civilians of the seven cities of Dalinghe, Xiaolinghe, Xingshan, Lianshan, and Tashan were terrified and burned the Fanggu and left. It can be seen that when the army and civilians retreated, they all "burned the houses and valleys and left", that is, the grain and houses were burned, and the strategy of "clearing the wilderness" was resolutely implemented, and the so-called "seven cities" here included all the cities before "Ningyuan", that is, Youtun, Jinzhou, Dalinghe, Xiaolinghe, Xingshan, Lianshan, and Tashan.

＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝

When I saw this paragraph, I once again couldn't help but admire the magic skills of the **** boss in cutting history books and passing the test in confusion.

Let's first cut the history book, the complete original text of this text is, "The soldiers are about to go to the right garrison, and the general Zhou Shoulian who defends the city has fled." The emperor ordered the eight officials to lead 40,000 infantry, and transported the coastal grain to the right guard. The soldiers advanced, and the Jinzhou guerrillas Xiao Sheng, Zhang Xian of the Chinese army, Lu Zhong of the Dusi, Zuo Fu of the Songshan staff general, Mao Fengyi of the Chinese army, and the soldiers and civilians of the seven cities of Dalinghe, Xiaolinghe, Xingshan, Lianshan, and Tashan were terrified and burned the Fanggu and left. "In the middle" the emperor ordered the eight officials to lead 40,000 infantry, and transport all the coastal grain to the right garrison" is just two short sentences, and there is no need to omit it compared to the length of the whole paragraph. And in the analysis of the first point above, we also saw that the **** boss pulled out these two sentences for analysis, and pretended to be clever to analyze the truth that 40,000 soldiers pulled 40,000 grains in one trip. But why omit it here? Take a look at the following:

Muddle. This sentence involves seven cities, and careless readers will not go to the point one by one, so the **** big guy kindly came to help, Youtun, Jinzhou, Daling River, Xiaoling River, Xingshan, Lianshan, Tashan, is it seven? Wrong! There is a Songshan in the middle of Jinzhou and Daling River! The seven cities are actually Jinzhou, Songshan, Daling River, Xiaoling River, Xingshan, Lianshan, Tashan, **** The big guy put the middle easy to attract people's attention "The emperor ordered eight officials to lead 40,000 infantry, and transported the coastal grain to store the right guard" This sentence was deliberately omitted, and then he pretended to help the readers who were too lazy to do it, so Shi Shiran mixed Youtun into the seven cities of "Burning the House Valley and leaving". In fact, the only granary in Jinzhou Road is Youtun, almost all the grain is in Youtun, Gao Di's own report said that "the slave thief coveted the grain of Youtun, and crossed the river around the fifteenth day of the first month." "The seven cities were burned, but Youtun was robbed, which is a typical throwing sesame seeds and picking up watermelons.

3. Another measure of Houjin shows that there is absolutely no "more than 100,000 stones of rice millet" in the grain here. Houjin arrived in Ningyuan on the 23rd, retreated from Ningyuan on the 26th, and burned the grain in Youtun when passing by Youtun on the 27th. "Qing Taizu Record" recorded: "On the 27th, the emperor returned to Youtunwei and burned all the grain and grass. "Seeing this, we can't help but ask, is this Nurhachi lacking heart? If the grain is going to be burned, why don't you burn it on the beach, and you have to use 40,000 people to move it to Youtun to burn it?

＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝

When he came, he was full of confidence in victory, so he collected grain in a hurry, and when he went back, he was beaten by a cannon and retreated in a hurry, so he hurriedly burned the grain and fled back to his hometown as soon as possible, is this difficult to understand? "Xizong Shilu" records, "(February of the sixth year) Bingzi, through a slightly higher report: The slaves attacked Ningyuan, shot a big leader, wrapped it in red cloth, and the thieves carried it away, let them cry loudly; divided the troops to attack Juehua Island, burned and plundered the grain and goods, and on the 28th, the general army opened the south gate of Mangui to chase it away...... Ren Wu, through a slightly higher Tang report: Dongyi soldiers in the right tun guard, sentry horses in the Daling River, thousands of Cao Gongcheng in Zizhang suddenly encountered, a little capture. "The Ming army is chasing all the way, can you escape so fast with grain and grass?

4. The grain obtained by Houjin at the seaside is by no means "rice millet", Gao Di reported on the sixth day of the first month: "The slave thief wants to covet the grain of Youtun, and crosses the river around the fifteenth day of the first month", indicating that there is indeed a considerable amount of grain in Youtun, and if you retreat in time, there will be enough time to safely transfer the "grain" of "Youtun" into Shanhaiguan, but people such as Jin Qi, who is "Governor of Tuntongju", and Yuan Chonghuan, who is "Ning Qiandao", have to disobey and disobey orders, which directly leads to the fact that there is no time for the "grain" to be transferred in time, and the Jin army is really as Gao Di said"Crossing the river around the fifteenth day of the first lunar month" panicked again, so he discarded some grain on the Youtun coast. This is the origin of the grain on the Youtun coast, but it is worth noting that since the grain is divided into "grain" and "material", then there must be a sequence when retreating, and the "rice millet" as the "grain" will naturally be withdrawn first, and the remaining grain on the Youtun coast must be more "material" rather than "grain".

＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝＝

First of all, in the matter of Jinyou's retreat and grain transshipment, Yuan Chonghuan and Jin Qiliang are not close to each other at all, which has been analyzed in the previous analysis of the official positions of the two.

Secondly, it is whether the grain in Youtun has been transferred. There is a more interesting record in December of the fifth year of the Apocalypse in the "Records of the Three Dynasties and Liao", "The saint Yu inherited the ancestors with a small bow...... However, in order to snatch the grain and grass of the right tun, it is used as a bait ......". From this point of view, although the Ming army withdrew the main force of Jinyou in October (see the previously quoted "due to the defeat of Liuhe, the old town was hastily withdrawn, and the right tun was stopped by the outpost to rest"), but the grain of the right tun was not withdrawn, and it was deliberately left as bait. This idea of using it as bait is very peculiar and goes against military common sense -- isn't it a thief to leave bait without soldiers? The "Records of the Three Dynasties and Liao" only records that there is such a statement in the holy decree of the Apocalypse, but it is not known whether the original proposer of this plan was Gao Di or the Ministry of War. However, according to common sense, it is more likely that the initiator is Gaodi. Looking at the first month of the sixth year of the Apocalypse, after the military department reported that Ningyuan started the war, there was another recital: "Bing Ke Luo Shangzhong inscribed: Closing the door to ask for grain in Sinong is nothing less than a cry, hearing that there is still a lot of accumulation in Youtun, he wants to move to the nearest place, and the fierce army proposes to grab grain, so he said. Now the slave and the camp moved to the right tun, not only to burn it, but also to tolerate the delay, otherwise it has been stolen funds...... "The apocalypse replied to this, "The saint said, this receit, it is really advisable to rush to the thief, such as the right tun grain and grass are lightly abandoned with thieves, and the retreat to Ningyuan has been lost, Ningyuan is an obstacle to closing the door, and the troops should be moved to help, and it cannot be divided into a rigid manner, and those who delay will be engaged in military law." It can be seen from here that there are three points: first, the previous statement that Youtun was used as bait is likely to be Gao Di's excuse, but in fact it could not be carried because of the fierce army's proposal to grab grain; second, Youtun never had any intention of transshipment of grain, at least until the start of the Ningyuan War, the imperial court did not receive Gao Di's such intention, so the military department and the emperor had this concern; third, incidentally, it can be seen that as soon as Ning Yuan started fighting, the apocalypse asked Gao Di to send troops to rescue, and the later fact was that Gao Di shrank, so he lost his official position because of this after the war.

Therefore, since Youtun has never had a plan or action to transfer grain, how could he have moved away the rice millet and left behind the fodder? Therefore, there is no doubt that Gao Di "entrusted more than 100,000 rice millet to be abandoned" mentioned in the "Biography of Yuan Chonghuan in the History of the Ming Dynasty"!

So far, let's review the logic of the **** boss planting Yuan Chonghuan:

1. Expand the jurisdiction of Jin Qiliang, Yuan Chonghuan's subordinate "Governor of Tuntongju", to the entire Liaodong Town, so as to plant Yuan Chonghuan for the failure to retreat from Youtun Grain. In fact, the post of general judge can only be the assistant of the chief official of the two administrative levels of the prefecture and county, and he has never been appointed as the assistant of a town as a "general judge", and Zhou Wenyu's "Bian Shi Xiaoji" clearly states that "Jin Qiliang and Ning Yuantong judge matters".

2. Through the imaginary Nurhachi sent 40,000 soldiers to transport 40,000 stone of grain at a time, it was "inferred" that Youtun only had 40,000 stone of grain, so as to push the other looted grain from Houjin to Juehua Island. In fact, sending 40,000 soldiers just to transport them all at once is the most whimsical speculation, and in fact Nurhachi sent 40,000 troops because he only had 40,000 unarmored soldiers.

3. By cutting the history books and passing the customs in confusion, Youtun is said to be one of the seven cities that "burned the house valley and left".

4. Unfounded fabrication that after Gao Di got the report that Houjin was going to rob Youtun, he began to order the transfer of grain. There was no record of this plan, order, or action.

5. According to the above 2, 3, and 4 articles, the amount of grain left in Gaodi Youtun in Youtun was greatly reduced, so as to overturn the record of all the grain burning of Juehua Island in at least five or six Ming and Qing history books (and also all), and at the same time overturn the record of Gaodi's "more than 100,000 rice millet abandoned" recorded in the "History of the Ming Dynasty", that is, all historical books were overturned with fabricated 3 pieces of evidence.

Click on the image link: